Question 1

What is opportunity cost in personal finance?

Accepted Answer

Opportunity cost is what you give up by choosing one option over another. In personal finance, spending $200/month on dining out means you are also forgoing the investment returns that money could have earned. The Money Time Machine makes that invisible cost visible and concrete.

Question 2

What return rate does the S&P 500 historically earn?

Accepted Answer

The S&P 500 has delivered an average nominal annual return of approximately 10% over its full history (1928 to present), including dividends reinvested. Inflation-adjusted (real) returns average roughly 7%, since the long-run CPI average is closer to 3%. The 10% nominal figure is the most widely used in long-term financial planning illustrations. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

Question 3

What is the historical return of the TSX?

Accepted Answer

The S&P/TSX Composite has returned approximately 7 to 8% per year on average in nominal terms over the long run. The TSX is more concentrated in financials, energy, and materials than the S&P 500, which partly explains the slightly lower long-run average, though it has outperformed during certain commodity-led periods.

Question 4

How is the inflation-adjusted view calculated?

Accepted Answer

When you toggle inflation adjustment on, the calculator applies the Fisher equation to each investment vehicle. The real monthly rate is calculated as: (1 + nominal rate / 12) divided by (1 + inflation rate / 12), minus 1. This real rate is then applied to the same ordinary annuity formula used for nominal results. For cash (0% nominal), the real rate is approximately negative 0.17% per month, meaning uninvested cash loses roughly 2% of its purchasing power each year. The 2% inflation rate used is the Bank of Canada's official target, in effect since 1993.

Question 5

Are these calculations accurate?

Accepted Answer

The math is precise. The calculator uses the standard future value of an ordinary annuity formula: PMT times ((1 + r)^n minus 1) divided by r, where r is the monthly rate and n is the number of months from January of your start year to today. The return rates shown are long-run historical averages from well-documented sources. What no calculator can predict is the actual sequence of returns you would have experienced starting in any specific year, or taxes on investment gains. Use these numbers as directional guidance, not a guarantee.

Question 6

Why does starting year matter so much?

Accepted Answer

Compound growth is exponential: the first dollars invested have the most time to grow. A dollar invested in 2010 has had over 15 years to compound at 8 to 10%, multiplying several times over. That same dollar invested in 2022 has had far less time. This is why small recurring amounts started early can dwarf large amounts started late.

Question 7

What about Canadian real estate?

Accepted Answer

Canadian home prices have risen roughly 6 to 7% annually on average nationally over the past two decades (CREA data), varying significantly by market. Real estate is not included as a direct investment vehicle because it cannot be invested in incrementally with a small monthly amount. It requires a large upfront purchase, ongoing costs (property tax, maintenance, insurance), geographic concentration, and leverage. It is a legitimate wealth-building tool, but it is not directly comparable to a monthly investment account.

Question 8

Is a HISA worth it compared to investing?

Accepted Answer

A HISA is appropriate for short-term savings and your emergency fund: the principal is guaranteed and you can withdraw at any time. For money you do not need for five or more years, a diversified index fund has historically produced significantly better returns. The trade-off is volatility. Stock markets decline, sometimes sharply, and you need the time horizon to recover. For money that must be available within one to three years, a HISA or GIC is usually the right call.

Question 9

Can I track multiple spending categories?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Use the category palette on the right side of the calculator to add as many spending categories as you like. Each category gets its own amount control. The results below reflect the combined total of everything you are tracking. For example, if you track $100/month for coffee and $50/month for streaming, the calculator runs on $150/month total.

Question 10

Can I use this tool for lump-sum investments instead of monthly?

Accepted Answer

This tool is designed for recurring monthly amounts, since that is how most spending habits work. For a lump-sum calculation, divide your total by the number of months in your period; the result will be close but not identical, since lump-sum investing has historically outperformed dollar-cost averaging in markets that trend upward over time.

The Money
Time Machine

Here's what you'd have today if you'd invested it instead

The opportunity gap

Ready to see your full retirement picture?

Add your spending habits

See five investment outcomes

Understand the real cost

Common questions

The MoneyTime Machine